Modi has no direct answers to Rahul Gandhi’s accusations

As the vote of no-confidence motion moved against  Narendra Modi led NDA government  has been defeated but Congress President Rahul Gandhi has emerged as a politician with leadership qualities.

The 2018 no-confidence motion debate that lasted 12-hours presented the broad themes that will dominate in the 2019 Lok Sabha elections. Rahul was at his best, specifically attacked Prime Minister on the specific commitments which Modi had made during 2014 and in the last fours he has failed to deliver.

Congress President  used the occasion to define the vision of his party  and setting the 2019 agenda by displaying that Congress is not in favour of divisive politics and believes in uniting India in a democratic manner.

He ambushed Modi on several issues of economic , defence and foreign policies including the social problems such as atrocities against Dalits, minorities, tribals and women safety prevailing across the country.

Rahul used the ammunition provided by Modi himself  against the NDA government  and termed that hollow promises  which Narendra Modi made during 2014 Lok Sabha elections were actually “Jumla strikes”- a 21st century political weapon of the saffron party .

The entire debate of no confidence motion  transformed into a politico-ideological fight with some significant outcomes: First, Rahul was extempore and cornered the government like never before and pin pointedly attack Narendra Modi and Amit Shah while PM Modi who is known as the best communicator ,was weak in his oratory; Second Rahul exposed Modi over the alleged corruption by Amit Shah son Jay Shah and categorically questioned the secrecy of the government for not divulging the details of the Rafale deal.

His most lethal attack came when he argued that  the UPA government had negotiated the deal at Rs 520 crore per aircraft, but after Modi’s visit to France  the price had shot up to Rs 1,600 crore a piece. Rahul questioned that why the maintenance contract, which had earlier been given to HAL through a technology transfer agreement was cancelled  and  given to Reliance Aerostructure, a joint venture between Anil Ambani’s Reliance Group and Dassault, the French company which manufactures the Rafale combat planes.The businessman, who has “never ever built an aircraft”, benefited from the deal to the tune of Rs 45,000 crore.

Congress president Rahul Gandhi launched a scathing attack on prime minister Narendra Modi and his government’s policies. He used the entire parliamentary exercise to make one allegation after another at the government, accusing both the prime minister and his ministers  in the cabinet of being “untruthful” to the Indian public.

Third, Rahul tore into BJP’s unfulfilled promises and hollow slogan of ‘sabka saath sabka vikas’ by directly accusing PM Modi of colluding with select rich businessman to benefit them and simultaneously marketing himself through advertisement for instance Jio advertisement carried Modi’s photos.

But PM Modi presented a weak speech by twisting each and every accusation made by the Congress President Rahul and refused to  respond why the price was increased exponentially, and why a businessman with no expertise in the aviation industry was granted the contract.

When he attacked Modi on Rafale deal and said PM is nervous to the extent that he is not looking into his eyes, PM  again applied the same tactic of twisting the accusations by labeling it an ST /SC argument  or Naamdaar and Kaamdaar .

Modi outrightly avoided to answer the speicific questions raised by Rahul and in turn gave bizarre arguments to prove that 2 crore jobs were generated every year .

It is interesting that PM Modi feel elated by singing the same tune for the last four years and has shunned the culture of listening to the problems of the poor and marginalized people.  “This government waived off Rs 2.5 lakh crore debts of around 20-25 richest people of India. But when lakhs of farmers request the prime minister with folded hands to give them some loan relief, Gandhi said implying that  crony capitalist practices  are being followed under Modi government  and talks or terming BJP as pro-poor is just a false propaganda.

PM Modi chooses to carry out personal attacks on Rahul and Sonia Gandhi but on the contrary the congress president preferred to maintain the ethical politics by reminding him about the failures of the government and the faulty decisions of Modi such as demnonetisation and GST  that ruined  MSME sector ,small traders and farmers who were largely dependent on cash transactions .

PM Modi’s speech was lengthy but has no answers on why he decided to not to raise Doklam issue in China and why he allowed Beijing to become a leader of South Asia, Why the people of India are being cheated by not divulging the details of Rafale deal,which otherwise ,PM Modi is duty bound to respond because taxpayers’ money is involved.

Rahul charged Modi of seriously compromising India’s security and said  while Modi was welcoming China’s president in Gujarat, Chinese soldiers had occupied Indian territory.“Modiji went to China but did not have any agenda. He refused to speak about Doklam which the Chinese army had illegally occupied. A lot of our soldiers had to die because of this agenda-less foreign policy,” he said.

To save his skin, Modi again mislead the nation by twisting the statement of Congress president, saying “Opposition is attacking soldiers on surgical strike. “

With folded hands, Rahul thanked Modi again for teaching him the meaning of what it is to be Hindu.When he walked across the aisle to embrace Modi, the Prime Minister chose to spurn that offer and confirmed that  he would continue to hate the Opposition.

He talks of ‘beti bachao Beti Padao’ but crime against women are on the increase and unemployment is rampant and if Modi continues to give absurd reasoning behind his concocted, fake and manufactured data of providing jobs, he is bound to face the music in 2019 lok Sabha polls. Modi said, “If we see passenger vehicles, then this sale figure was 25,40,000. Out of that, if 25 per cent was a replacement of old vehicles, then 20 lakh new vehicles were on the roads. Even if 25 per cent of these new vehicles get a driver and conductor, then 5 lakh new jobs were created.”

Blog: By Arti Bali,
arti

(Senior Journalist)

 

Total
1
Shares
Related Posts