Farmers Have Right To Protest, But Can’t Block Roads: Supreme Court

Farmers Protest

New Delhi: The farmers’ protest must continue and Delhi cannot be blocked, the Supreme Court said today while hearing a series of petitions on the issue. Chief Justice of India SA Bobde, who said yesterday that the matter must be handed over to a committee, said the panel must have “independent members with knowledge of agriculture and hear both sides and give report on what is to be done”. Meanwhile, the “protests can continue without violence and the police will not do anything,” the Chief Justice said.

When the Centre insisted on a meeting where discussions can held on each clause, the court said, “We observed yesterday that the Centre is not successful in negotiations. We do not think that the farmers will accept your conclusions. Let the committee decide”.

When senior advocate Harish Salve said “Protests cannot be just for protest, but to articulate point of view,” the court said, “That is exactly what we mean”.

“Protest’s purpose must be fulfilled by non-violent means. Protests must be about issues. Aggrieved parties must be allowed to articulate and the party that caused the problem must be allowed to answer,” said Chief Justice Bobde.


Farm laws: CJI says notice has to go all protesting farmers’ bodies & suggests that case to be placed before a vacation bench of the court during winter break.

AG says notice has to be served to all the farmers’ representatives who have been part of the government talks so far

Purpose of staging protest can be achieved if farmers and govt hold talks and we wish to facilitate that, says SC

Farm laws matter in Supreme Court: The independent committee can have P Sainath, Bhartiya Kisan Union and others as members, suggests CJI

You (farmers) cannot instigate violence and cannot block a city like this, adds CJI

“The first and the only thing we will decide today is regarding the farmers’ protest and the fundamental right of citizens to move. The question of the validity of laws can wait,” says Surpeme Court

Related Posts